India’s third Test against England at Lord’s was expected to be a turning point for Karun Nair, a player whose Test career has long lingered on the fringes despite a record triple century to his name. But after yet another underwhelming outing, his comeback might already be under threat.
Flashes of Class, But No Substance
In six innings since his return to Test cricket, Karun has managed 131 runs at an average of 21.83, with a top score of 40. These are not disastrous numbers, but in a series where most top-order batters have cashed in on flat tracks, Karun’s inability to convert starts into significant scores stands out.
At Lord’s, he was dismissed for just 14, offering no shot to a ball from Brydon Carse that rapped him on the pads. His first innings knock of 40 showed some fluency, but like his other starts this series, it fell short of being impactful.
A Triple Century That Now Feels Distant
Karun’s unbeaten 303 against England in Chennai back in 2016 remains only the third triple century by an Indian in Tests, but that historic knock has ironically become more of a burden than a badge. Despite consistent domestic performances for Vidarbha and Northamptonshire, he has not yet replicated that level of dominance on the international stage since his return.
Selection Dilemma: Stick or Twist?
With a 10-day gap before the fourth Test in Manchester, captain Shubman Gill and head coach Gautam Gambhir have a decision to make. Do they persist with Karun Nair, banking on his experience and glimpses of form, or pivot to Sai Sudharsan, the young left-hander who debuted in Leeds?
Sudharsan didn’t have an explosive debut (0 and 30), but as a future prospect, he could offer a long-term option at No. 3. A left-handed option also helps break the monotony of a right-dominated top order.
Karun’s Mental Battle: The Fight Within
To his credit, Karun hasn’t looked nervous or out of place. He’s shown technical control and composure at the crease. But Test cricket often demands more than just looking the part. It requires the ability to deliver under pressure, something he hasn’t done consistently in this comeback.
Adding to his woes are some exceptional dismissals: a stunning slip catch by Joe Root, a diving grab from Ollie Pope, and now a misjudged leave that cost him dearly. These may seem unlucky, but in the eyes of selectors, what counts is the scoreboard.
The Road Ahead: Redemption or Rejection?
Whether Karun gets another chance could come down to team strategy—are the management looking to reward consistency or invest in youth? Gill and Gambhir will no doubt weigh loyalty against long-term vision.
If Karun is dropped, it may seem harsh, but he would likely acknowledge the missed opportunities. If he’s retained, it could be his last opportunity to justify the faith. In either case, the message is clear: starts aren’t enough anymore—the team needs match-defining knocks.
Karun Nair’s 2024 England Series Stats
| Match | Innings | Runs | Highest Score | Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Test 1 (Headingley) | 2 | 0, 20 | 20 | 10.00 |
| Test 2 (Nottingham) | 2 | 31, 26 | 31 | 28.50 |
| Test 3 (Lord’s) | 2 | 40, 14 | 40 | 27.00 |
| Total | 6 | 131 | 40 | 21.83 |
Final Word
Karun Nair is walking a tightrope. The fourth Test may decide whether his international story gets a fresh chapter—or an early closure. For now, all eyes are on Manchester.
Stay tuned for all the latest Cricket news, match highlights, player analysis and viral moments!