West Indies captain Roston Chase did not hold back in his criticism of the umpiring standards during the first Test against Australia at Barbados. After suffering a 159-run loss, Chase voiced serious concerns over several decisions that went against the hosts, suggesting they played a crucial role in determining the match’s outcome.
The controversy began as early as Day 1 when a caught-behind decision involving Travis Head was ruled in the batter’s favour despite visual evidence suggesting a clean catch. The issue escalated on Day 2 when Roston Chase was declared out LBW by third umpire Adrian Holdstock, even though a potential inside edge was visible. Another incident involving Shai Hope’s dismissal to a questionable catch from Alex Carey further intensified the West Indies’ frustration.
Chase, visibly upset after the match, said these “questionable calls” cost his team a chance to take control of the game. He stated that his dismissal, along with Hope’s, disrupted a promising partnership that could have given the Windies a crucial lead.
“This game is frustrating for me and for the team. We bowled Australia out for a relatively low score. But then there were so many questionable calls in the game, and none went our way. You’re giving it your all, you’re fighting, and then nothing is going your way,” Chase said.
Frustration boils over in post-match comments
West Indies coach Daren Sammy also met with match referee Javagal Srinath after Day 2, calling for more consistency in umpiring decisions. According to Chase, repeated incorrect decisions not only affect the match outcome but can also derail a player’s career.
“It’s clear anyone would feel bad about those decisions. You’re out there playing to win, giving your best, and it seems like everyone is against you. It’s frustrating. When players mess up, we get penalised. But officials don’t face any consequences. One bad decision can break a player’s career,” said Chase.
He went on to demand that match officials be held accountable for errors, just as players are. “There should be some penalty put in place when blatant decisions go against you,” he added.
ICC may step in
Both Chase and coach Sammy now risk potential sanctions from the ICC for publicly commenting on match officials. However, their remarks have sparked a broader conversation about accountability in cricket officiating, especially in high-stakes matches.
Australia lead the three-match series 1-0. The second Test will be crucial for West Indies as they aim to bounce back both on the field and in spirit.
Stay tuned for all the latest Cricket news, match highlights, player analysis and viral moments!